Tolerance across the stars or: Oh God, not another Star Trek post
I have plenty of time to think about stupid crap these days, and when it’s cold and rainy in late June, that tends to happen more than usual. So, while reading an article about how there are approximately two billion planets like ours in the Milky Way, my mind drifted towards – what else - Star Trek.
I can remember a question back when Star Trek: Voyager got its unfortunate start: aren’t you guys running out of room in the galaxy to meet new aliens? Of course, the premise of Voyager (and even the superior Deep Space Nine, to a degree) put it simply: of course not. But it was an idea that stuck in the back of my mind throughout the years. Eventually, the Federation and other factions in the Star Trek universe are going to run out of places to visit. After seeing the above article, I realize once again that they’ve barely scratched the surface, if you were to take any Star Trek map seriously.

Fig 1: The relative size of territories in the Alpha and Beta Quadrants indicates th-NEEEEEEERRRRRRRD
Once a question gets answered, though, you tend to end up with more questions. What I’m pondering now is, how come the only place in the galaxy that you meet all sorts of aliens in one place is the United Federation of Planets? As you may know (or not, if you have a life), the UFP is the Roddenberrian utopia in which everybody gets along, nobody needs to work a day job, and everyone is on the metric system. Strangely, there’s only one planet where they still play baseball. In the UFP, you’ve got humans, Vulcans, Andorians, Bolians, Tellarites, Betazoids, and countless other races living together in perfect harmony. Essentially, as the Federation expands, they treat everyone they come across with an “I’m okay, you’re okay” attitude and ask them to join their club. If yes, cool, if not, no big deal.
Meanwhile, there’s other reaches of the galaxy where you’ve got the stock “other races,” like the Klingons, Romulans, Cardassians, the Borg, etc. Not all of these are “bad guys,” but they’ve got quite a bit of territory and differing ideologies. What I’m beginning to realize is, whenever you see the bridge of a Klingon ship, you only see Klingons. Same for the rest of the guys I listed. What does this say about their modus operandi? It varies per race, of course. The Klingons are kind of like vikings, getting into fights and singing songs around campfires, but they’ve still got families at home. The Romulans are Vulcans who got fed up with the whole “you can only have sex once every seven years” thing and adopted a Roman aesthetic. The Cardassians are like the Greeks – Athenian home life with Spartan discipline everywhere else. But we hardly ever see other alien races within their ranks. I remember a guy from the Federation defecting to the Romulan Empire once, but that was actually better for a laugh than anything.
You have to assume that, like the UFP, these other races encountered different aliens as they expanded. What happens to them? When it comes to say, the Borg, they just Borgify you and that’s it. The Cardassians enslaved people, most notably the Bajorans; this was one of the major plot devices at the start of DS9. The Klingons aren’t into such things and are above genocide as well. The Romulans, however, put the genetically similar Remans into labor camps for decades, so who knows what would happen to someone they don’t look like?

Finally, an excuse to use this joke.
Curiously, there’s one major faction that allowed other races to serve among their ranks, the Dominion. Unlike the UFP, however, the Dominion were solely motivated by power. Their methods included diplomacy, as well as infiltration and manipulation; when those didn’t work, they conquered you. On the surface they appeared to be another example of harmonious living. Instead, it was an interstellar facist state controlled through fear – by a mysterious group of aliens who convinced their subordinates of being gods.
Maybe a lot of this can be attributed to the fact that the whole of the Star Trek canon has been developed over several decades, and with each era comes different motivations. Like all good sci-fi, Trek has been holding a mirror to the important issues of the day. The Klingon conflicts represented Cold War relations with the Russians (watch Star Trek VI for the happy ending), the Romulans were born out of race relations and took off from there, and so forth. DS9 used Bajor as a stand-in for the Middle East – politically and theologically – throughout its run. The Borg were just scary all around.
What I’m trying to say is, from the writing standpoint, all of these races were intended to be broad. When the story continues to develop, though, you have to develop the groups that are involved. Why didn’t we get to see varied ranks on other ships? Because the writers didn’t think of it. Yes, even when you take it that seriously, you’ve got to remember: it’s just a TV show.

"Here's your toll, Troll."
EDIT: Now is as good a time as ever to point out that Mac from It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia looks just like this guy.























